YANG Xiaoju, GUO Qinglin, YU Zongren, CHEN Songcong , WU Fasi
Earthen sites are architectural relics with important historical, cultural,and scientific values in human history. This paper uses bibliometric methods to analyze the current research status on earthen sites by reviewing the international research published between 1950 and 2023 collected in the China National Knowledge Infrastructure (CNKI) and Web of Science (WOS) databases. The results show that the number of published research papers in the CNKI and WOS has been increasing steadily year by year,and that the two countries with the highest number of published papers are China and Spain. According to the CNKI database,these papers are largely concentrated in journals such as Cultural Relics Protection and Archaeological Science,Archaeology,and Dunhuang Research,which mainly focus on the disciplines of archaeology,architectural science and engineering,tourism,and geology;most of the field research for these articles has been carried out by research institutions in northwest China,including Lanzhou University,Dunhuang Academy,and Northwest University. It is also scholars from these institutions who have published the majority of papers related to the stability and weathering of archaeological sites and the materials and technologies applied to conservation and reinforcement,notably Chen Wenwu,Wang Xudong,and Li Zuixiong. In the WOS database,the top-ranking journals are Construction and Building Materials and International Journal of Architectural Heritage,while the papers they include are mainly related to civil engineering and construction technology;the research published in these journals is primarily conducted by Oxford University and undertaken by scholars from Spain,Britain,and
the United States,with a focus on earthquakes,weathering,and measurement modeling. Cooperation between research institutions is influenced by various factors such as geographical location,the research goals of the authors,and the earthen sites available for in situ investigation. Funding and research support for the study of earthen sites is primarily supported by the National Natural Science Foundation,the National Science and Technology Support Plan,and the National Key Research and Development Plan,in China;as well as the European Commission. Future interdisciplinary research in this field will likely focus on issues such as weathering, water-salt erosion,and freeze-thaw damage,and significant breakthroughs are expected to be made in in-situ detection technology,the diagnosis of deterioration mechanisms,detecting degradation in earthen sites under multiple field couplings,the research and development of conservation materials,and the construction of a quality evaluation system forconservation engineering projects.